Science1 publisherNot yet confirmed elsewhere2 min readPublished
Spins in a ytterbium compound pick a shared axis 110 kelvin above its magnetic ordering point
Rice physicists led by Pengcheng Dai find spins in YbMnBi2 favouring some directions from about 400 K, though magnetic order only sets in at 290 K. The team proposes this 'spin nematic' state is why the compound deflects charge and heat currents so strongly in a magnetic field.
The Scientist · Science desk

What happened
- A closely related compound with calcium in place of ytterbium, measured the same way, showed no sign of the direction-dependent spin fluctuations.
- The team set the spin orientation of neutrons fired at the crystals and compared how the spins fluctuated along different directions as temperature and magnetic field changed.
- The team proposes that heavy ytterbium atoms tie electron motion to spin, and that in a field the ytterbium spins form a twisted arrangement that deflects moving electrons.
- The work, with Yaofeng Xie as first author, is published in Physical Review X.
Compiled by The ScientistSomething wrong?How this is made
Why it matters
- constraint Any account of YbMnBi2's sideways currents has to work across a band of about 110 K where spins prefer a direction but do not order, so models built on ordered magnetism alone cannot cover the whole effect.
- precedent The calcium swap is a test other groups can copy: measure a sibling compound without the heavy atom and check whether the direction preference disappears before claiming a spin nematic.
- capability If the proposed transport link holds, spintronics work gains a candidate effect that needs no magnetic order and operates in a temperature band that includes room temperature.
YbMnBi2 had an odd habit. In a magnetic field, currents of electricity and heat moving through it are pushed sideways far more strongly than expected. They keep being pushed at temperatures where the compound's magnetic order has vanished [5]. Above its ordering temperature, an ordinary magnet's spins point in random directions [3]. Until now the behaviour had lacked a convincing explanation [5].
Earlier studies had suggested that some magnetic compounds host an in-between state, the spin nematic. In it, spins share a preferred direction without forming magnetic order, much as the rod-shaped molecules in a liquid crystal display do [4]. A state like that has no static magnetic pattern to detect. What it does have is uneven fluctuation: spins move more along some directions than others. That is why the experiment used neutrons, which carry spins of their own, with the experimenters setting the orientation of the beam's spins [7].
The unevenness appeared near 400 K as the crystal cooled from 450 K. Magnetic order arrives only around 290 K [8]. In Celsius, the nematic window runs from roughly 127 C down to 17 C [13], a band about 110 K wide [12].
The calcium sibling is the part of the design I find most persuasive [6]. It lacked the effect [9]. If manganese and bismuth were enough to produce the anisotropy, the calcium compound should have shown it too. The thing this doesn't tell you is which property of ytterbium matters, because the comparison isolates the atom and not its properties. The team's candidate is weight: heavy ytterbium ties the motion of electrons closely to their spins [10]. The paper's title calls the resulting twisted arrangement scalar spin chirality [11].
The neutron measurements are direct evidence for a fluctuating spin nematic, and phys.org's account calls the calcium result strong evidence for it [9]. The step from that state to the sideways currents is the team's proposed mechanism [10]. The phys.org account does not report a measurement or calculation that matches the size of the deflection to the measured fluctuations.
According to phys.org, the work could guide attempts to produce similar effects in other materials. It could also feed into spintronics, which carries information in spin instead of electric charge [14]. The account calls the effect especially promising for practical devices because it appears without magnetic order and at around room temperature [15]. I'd hold that view loosely. A chip needs the effect in a form it can build with, and these measurements were made on crystals of the compound [6].
What to watch
- A measurement or calculation that matches the size of YbMnBi2's sideways current deflection to the measured nematic fluctuations.
- Whether other compounds with heavy atoms on a similar lattice show the same direction-dependent fluctuations above their ordering temperatures.
- Whether the effect survives in thin films or other device-scale samples near room temperature.
Clarity's read
What the record supports and how the coverage leans. The claims behind it follow.
Reality
- Evidence55
- Adoption
- Insufficient
- Hype gap+25
- Incentives
- Insufficient
- Confidence50
Claim ledger
Ranked by verification strength, evidence, and original report placement.
- [1]
Researchers led by Pengcheng Dai at Rice University found that in a compound containing ytterbium, spins behave much like the molecules in a liquid crystal, favouring a certain direction without lining up to create magnetism on larger scales.
- [2]
The research, by Yaofeng Xie et al, is published in Physical Review X (2026).
- [3]
In ordinary magnets, spins line up to create an overall magnetization, but this order breaks down above a certain temperature, leaving the spins pointing in random directions.
- [4]
Previous studies suggested some magnetic compounds may host an in-between 'spin nematic' state in which, like rod-shaped molecules in a liquid crystal display, spins share a preferred direction without forming magnetic order.
- [5]
In a magnetic field, currents of electricity and heat flowing through YbMnBi2 are pushed sideways far more strongly than expected, even at temperatures where its magnetic order has vanished; this behaviour has lacked a convincing explanation.
- [6]
The researchers fired beams of neutrons at crystals of YbMnBi2 and at a closely related compound in which ytterbium is replaced by calcium.
- [7]
Because neutrons carry spins, the team controlled their orientation and measured how they scattered off the spins in each crystal, comparing how the spins fluctuated along different directions while varying temperature and applied magnetic field strength.
- [8]
Cooling the ytterbium compound from 450 K, the team found that at around 400 K its manganese spins began fluctuating more strongly in some directions than others, while magnetic order sets in only at around 290 K.
- [9]
The calcium compound showed no sign of the effect, which phys.org describes as strong evidence for a fluctuating spin nematic state.
- [10]
Dai's team proposes the state arises because heavy ytterbium atoms tie the motion of electrons closely to their spins; in a magnetic field, the ytterbium spins interact with this state, creating a twisted spin arrangement that deflects moving electrons.
- [11]
The paper is titled 'Spin Nematic Liquid Crystal and Scalar Spin Chirality in Tetragonal Lattice YbMnBi2'.
- [12]
The window in which the manganese spins show a preferred direction without magnetic order is about 110 K wide.
- [13]
In Celsius, the nematic window runs from roughly 127 C down to roughly 17 C.
- [14]
According to phys.org, the results could guide efforts to create similar effects in other materials and could bring advances in spintronics, a technology that carries information using spin instead of electrical charge.
- [15]
Phys.org says that because the effect appears without magnetic order and at around room temperature, it could be especially promising for practical devices.
Sources
1 independent publisher whose own reporting we read for this story.
- phys.orgLiquid-crystal-like magnetism explains puzzling properties in a rare-earth compound
1 article · October 8, 2026
Topics and entities
Follow any of these and your For You feed starts watching them — no settings page required.
Topics
- Spin nematic statesFollow
- Spintronics and Spin TexturesFollow
- Condensed Matter PhysicsFollow
- Neutron scatteringFollow
Entities
- Pengcheng DaiFollow
- Yaofeng XieFollow
- Rice UniversityFollow
- YbMnBi2Follow
- Physical Review XFollow