Science1 publisher3 min readPublished
Hokkaido fossil found in 1995 is named one of Asia's three known nodosaurid species
S. Oyabu and colleagues named Nipponopelta yezoensis from CT scans of a 1995 Hokkaido fossil, one of only three nodosaurid species known from Asia. Its North American anatomy fits a Bering land-bridge crossing, though Asia's patchy fossil record limits the inference.
The Scientist · Science desk
What happened
- A research team revisited an armored-dinosaur fossil first found in 1995 on Hokkaido, Japan's northernmost main island.
- From CT scans and anatomical analysis, the team named a new nodosaurid species, Nipponopelta yezoensis, after Japan and Yezo, the traditional name for Hokkaido.
- The new species is one of only three nodosaurids known from Asia, a group whose fossils come mostly from North America and Europe.
- The team found it closely related to North American nodosaurids and suggests its ancestors crossed the Bering land bridge 100 million to 110 million years ago.
Compiled by The ScientistSomething wrong?How this is made
Why it matters
- constraint With only three Asian species in the tally, one new nodosaurid from an inland Asian formation would weaken the scarcity half of the migration argument.
- contradiction Zelenitsky's coastal-dispersal picture and Mallon's point about eroded uplands imply different ranges for nodosaurids, and the known fossils cannot yet tell the two apart.
- constraint Because this animal postdates the proposed crossing, it cannot document the route itself; testing that needs older nodosaurids from northeast Asia or Alaska.
- capability Non-destructive CT work let a partial specimen found decades ago be described as a new species, so other old specimens can be re-examined without damaging them.
According to the study, the Bering proposal rests on two observations: the animal looks anatomically like North American nodosaurids, and nodosaurids are scarce in Asia [19]. The second is the weaker. A tally of three species also records which rocks survived and which were searched. Darla Zelenitsky, a co-author at the University of Calgary, made that point about her own result. Zelenitsky said the scarcity could reflect the rock record, or simply that nodosaurids were not able to diversify as much in Asia [14].
The closest thing the account offers to a control is the club-tailed side of the family. Nodosaurids are plated relatives of the ankylosaurids, minus the tail club [9]. Several ankylosaurid species have been found further inland in Asia, while few nodosaurid fossils have turned up anywhere on the continent [15]. Jordan Mallon, a paleontologist at the Canadian Museum of Nature who was not involved, pointed to the rocks that are missing altogether. Upland and mountainous regions erode and leave few fossils, so nodosaurids could have lived there and left no record [12]. "It's very hard to tell a comprehensive story when you've only got a few pages out of a phone book's worth of time," Mallon said [13].
The dates limit what this specimen can show. The bones are 93 million to 100 million years old [3]. The proposed crossing falls between 100 million and 110 million years ago [6]. On the team's reading, the Hokkaido animal descends from the migrants. It lived anywhere from the end of that window to 17 million years after its oldest date [17].
Oyabu and colleagues describe the animal in the February 2027 issue of Cretaceous Research [7]. They worked from the back of a skull, part of a lower jaw, several teeth and some bony plates [3]. CT scanning turned that material into digital 3D models. Victoria Arbour of the Royal B.C. Museum, who was not involved, said the method "lets you just get more information than you'd be able to have otherwise, because you can look inside without breaking [the fossil]" [16]. The published account does not report how strongly the analysis supports the North American placement.
A separate team first found the bones in marine sediments. Nodosaurids did not live in the sea, so the carcass was probably carried out along a river or estuary before it sank [10]. Other nodosaurids come from similar marine deposits. Zelenitsky said a coastal life may have helped the animals spread across the land bridge by following the shore [11].
Mallon wants more bones. "It incites us to keep digging so that we can learn more about this animal and test some of our ideas about just what it is," he said [18].
What to watch
- More Nipponopelta yezoensis bones from Hokkaido would test a placement built from a partial skull, jaw, teeth and plates.
- Nodosaurid finds in the inland Asian formations that already yield ankylosaurids would bear directly on whether Asian scarcity is real or a preservation effect.