Science1 publisher3 min readPublished
Light reads hidden octupolar magnetism from the handedness of crystal vibrations
University of Toronto physicists say hidden eight-pole magnetic order leaves a handedness in crystal vibrations that light can read. Ordinary probes miss this 'octupolar' state, so researchers can now look for it before anyone tries to build memory from it.
The Scientist · Science desk

What happened
- Co-author Swati Chaudhary of the University of Tokyo says the onset of octupolar order gives certain phonon modes a distinct handedness, which the team names pseudo-chiral.
- According to the university's account, aiming a special type of rotating light at magnetic materials revealed a clear optical fingerprint of the hidden order.
- The study, with Toronto professor Arun Paramekanti as senior author, appears in Physical Review Letters as 'Pseudochiral Phonons from Octupolar Magnetic Order'.
Compiled by The ScientistSomething wrong?How this is made
Why it matters
- capability A magnetic order that ordinary probes cannot register now has an optical signature, so whether a given crystal hosts it becomes a testable question.
- decision Groups holding candidate octupolar crystals have a case for adding rotating-light phonon measurements to their standard magnetic characterization.
- constraint Memory devices would need the order switched as well as detected, and co-author Kathleen Hart describes control through atomic vibrations as an eventual goal.
A dipole magnet has two poles, north and south [1]. In octupolar order, a pattern of particles in a crystal behaves as if it had eight [2]. The university's account calls detecting and controlling such states a significant challenge [3]. "We identified new signatures of a hidden type of magnetic state which cannot be detected using ordinary probes," said Arun Paramekanti, a University of Toronto physics professor and the study's senior author [6][5].
The method is indirect. It uses light to probe the atomic vibrations produced as electrons spin [4]. Those vibrations move through the crystal lattice as packets of energy called phonons, and the team looked for chiral phonons, ones that do not match their own mirror image [7]. "Just as a left hand cannot fit cleanly over a right hand even though they are mirror images, chiral phonons have a 'handedness' and exist in distinct, non-matching forms," said lead author Rory Sutcliffe, a Toronto physics doctoral candidate [8].
Handedness links the vibrations to the hidden order. "We found that the onset of octupolar order can impart a distinct handedness to certain phonon modes," said Swati Chaudhary, a project research associate at the University of Tokyo and a co-author [10]. "These vibrations behave differently from those found in conventional magnets, so we call them 'pseudo-chiral' phonons, and they provide a new way of identifying and studying hidden magnetic states," she said [11]. To read that handedness, the team aimed what the release describes as a special type of rotating light at magnetic materials [9].
The design has one property I like a great deal. The handedness arrives with the onset of the order [10], so a sample can be its own control. I'd expect the persuasive version of this result to be one crystal measured on both sides of the point where the order sets in, with the pseudo-chiral signal present only on the ordered side. According to the university, the team observed "a clear optical fingerprint of the otherwise hidden magnetic order" [9]. The release does not name the material studied or report how large that signal was, and another lab would need both before trying the method on its own compounds.
The applications are several steps further on. The university calls the work a critical first step toward harnessing multipolar magnetism for data storage and computing [14]. "Our research opens up the possibility for using higher-order magnets in several applications including controllable read-write memory elements found in everyday computers," Paramekanti said [13]. Kathleen Hart, a Toronto physics doctoral candidate and co-author, said the work "lays the foundation for how such octupolar magnetism might eventually be controlled through atomic vibrations within a material" [12].
What to watch
- Measurements that name the host material and report the size of the pseudo-chiral signal above and below the point where octupolar order sets in.
- An independent group reproducing the pseudo-chiral phonon signature in a different candidate octupolar material.
- Any demonstration that driving phonons can switch octupolar order, the control step Hart describes as the eventual aim.