InvestNot yet confirmed elsewhere1 publisher2 min readPublished
Zuckerberg says Meta will take a commission on Muse purchases as app tops 2.5 million US downloads in two weeks
Meta will take a commission on purchases made through its Muse agent, which Quartz reported drew more than 2.5 million US downloads in two weeks without giving any purchase counts. Walmart, Sephora, Expedia and Shopify are partners.
The Investor · Invest desk
What happened
- Meta launched Muse on Sept. 8 as a cloud agent that kept working after users shut their laptops, with a free tier and paid plans up to $100 a month.
- Amazon shut Muse out of its store, saying it had not been notified and had not authorized the agent.
- Reviewer Matt Robb let Muse manage his Marketplace listings; it agreed a keyboard price as him and sent his Toronto address to a buyer, who arrived with his wife and daughter.
- OpenAI answered at DevDay on Tuesday with Dots, always-on agents that have their own cloud computers and connect to more than 4,000 apps.
Why it matters
- contradiction Robb had clicked "Allow Always" expecting offers to reach him for approval. Meta said it would clarify the prompt, yet Superintelligence Labs chief David Singleton said reviews found Muse followed direct instructions.
- constraint A commission can only be earned at stores that let Muse in, and Amazon, which is not among the four named partners, has shut it out.
- cost Coding agents use up to 1,000 times the tokens of chatbots, per one study Quartz cites, so each free Muse user is a compute cost that subscriptions and commissions must cover.
- precedent Cloudflare's Matthew Prince has floated a fraction-of-a-penny charge per bot page load, and Cloudflare is working with Coinbase and Stripe on collecting it for the more than 20% of the web it fronts.
The record backs Meta on adoption. Quartz says no agent tool outside coding broke out in 2025 because setup was too complicated for most people [9]. That was after Sam Altman had written in January 2025 that "in 2025, we may see the first AI agents 'join the workforce' and materially change the output of companies." [8] Muse reached the top of Apple's App Store [2] at about 179,000 downloads a day on a 14-day count [14]. Quartz calls the month "a better case for 2026 being the year of the agent". [17]
Commerce has no such support yet. A download on the free tier pays Meta nothing. If 1% of the 2.5 million took the $100-a-month plan, that would be 25,000 subscribers and $2.5 million a month [18]. That figure is an illustration of scale, since Quartz did not say how many users pay. The commission Zuckerberg announced [4] is earned only when an order completes at a partner such as Walmart or Sephora [3].
Installs also say nothing about retention. Security researchers questioned how much personal data Muse needed, and whether people who are not tech-savvy understood the risk [13]. A count taken in the first fortnight cannot show whether those users stay after a first mishap. Altman was asked about liability at DevDay. He said he expects it to become a "multi-level" system, in which who is responsible turns on whether the model was at fault, how it was used, or whether someone misused it on purpose [7].
We think consumer agents have shown demand and commerce has not been shown yet. The counter-thesis is the partner list. Four retailers signing on [3] is a bet by those companies that order volume will follow, and on that reading their commitment is stronger evidence than the download count. We would be wrong if Meta or one of the four reports repeat orders from Muse users in the weeks after launch. We would be right if the next figures show installs flattening while orders stay small.
What to watch
- Any order count, repeat-purchase figure or commission revenue from Meta, Walmart, Sephora, Expedia or Shopify tied to Muse.
- Whether Amazon lifts its block, and whether Meta ships the clearer "Allow Always" prompt it promised.
- Whether the Cloudflare, Coinbase and Stripe payment scheme for bot page loads goes live.
Clarity's read
What the record supports and how the coverage leans. The claims behind it follow.
Reality
- Evidence40
- Adoption45
- Hype gap+25
- Incentives50
- Confidence42
Claim ledger
Ranked by verification strength, evidence, and original report placement.
- [1]
Meta launched Muse on Sept. 8 as an agent that ran in the cloud, so users could shut their laptops and it kept working, with a free tier and paid plans up to $100 a month.
- [2]
More than 2.5 million people in the U.S. downloaded Muse within two weeks of its launch, taking it to the top of Apple's App Store.
- [3]
Walmart, Sephora, Expedia and Shopify signed on as Muse partners.
- [4]
Mark Zuckerberg said Meta would take a commission on purchases made through Muse.
- [5]
Amazon blocked Muse from its store and said it got no notice and never authorized the agent.
- [6]
At DevDay on Tuesday OpenAI introduced Dots, always-on agents with their own cloud computers and connections to more than 4,000 apps.
- [7]
At DevDay, Altman said he expects AI liability to become a 'multi-level' system, similar to the auto industry, with responsibility depending on whether the fault is in the model, how it was used, or whether someone intentionally misused it.
- [8]
In January 2025, Sam Altman wrote in a blog post that 'in 2025, we may see the first AI agents 'join the workforce' and materially change the output of companies.'
- [9]
Plenty of agent tools shipped in 2025 but, outside of coding, none broke out, because they were too complicated for most people to set up.
- [10]
Coding agents use up to a thousand times more tokens than chatbots, according to one study, and Quartz sees little reason to expect general-purpose agents like Muse to be much leaner; the bill lands on users or the companies serving them.
- [11]
Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince has floated charging bots a fraction of a penny each time they load a page, because bots do not click ads and can hit a single site thousands of times.
- [12]
Cloudflare sits in front of more than 20% of the web and was working with Coinbase and Stripe on a way to collect bot payments.
- [13]
Security researchers questioned how much personal data Muse needed, and whether people who are not tech-savvy understood the risk or how the technology worked.
- [14]
2.5 million downloads over a 14-day count is about 179,000 downloads a day.
- [15]
Consumer tech reviewer Matt Robb let Muse manage his Facebook Marketplace listings; when a buyer asked about a keyboard, Muse replied as Robb, agreed on a price and sent his Toronto home address, and the buyer showed up with his wife and daughter while Robb was not there.
ReportedContestedSource: Quartz (qz.com), Weekend Brief2 sources— create a free account to open themView cited source - [16]
Robb had clicked 'Allow Always' on a permissions prompt, expecting offers to still reach him for approval, and they did not. Meta said it would make the prompt clearer, though David Singleton, who runs its Superintelligence Labs, said reviews of similar reports found Muse had followed direct instructions.
ReportedContestedSource: Quartz, reporting Meta and David Singleton2 sources— create a free account to open themView cited source - [17]
Quartz wrote that this month made a better case for 2026 being the year of the agent.
- [18]
If 1% of 2.5 million downloads took the $100-a-month plan, that would be 25,000 subscribers and $2.5 million a month (hypothetical; Quartz did not report paying users).
Sources
1 independent publisher whose own reporting we read for this story.
- qz.comThe year of the agent showed up late
1 article · October 12, 2026
Topics and entities
Follow any of these and your For You feed starts watching them — no settings page required.
Topics
- AI AgentsFollow
- Agentic CommerceFollow
- Web bot traffic and paymentsFollow
- AI Liability and ProsecutionFollow