Science1 publisher2 min readPublished
Swarming bacteria and human airway cells curl their topological defects into spirals
Standard active nematic theory sends paired defects along straight, mirrored lines. A Ben-Gurion-led team reports in Nature Physics that it measured curved, co-rotating paths in swarming bacteria and in human bronchial cells.
The Scientist · Science desk

What happened
- A team led from Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, with collaborators at Bar-Ilan University and the University of Geneva, tracked topological defects in living matter and published the work in Nature Physics.
- Standard active nematic theory has defect pairs meeting and parting along straight mirrored lines; in swarming Bacillus subtilis and crawling human bronchial epithelial cells the pairs co-rotated along spirals.
- The authors built an active nemato-polar model that adds chemically fuelled polar self-propulsion to an otherwise nematically ordered system to reproduce what they saw.
Compiled by The ScientistSomething wrong?How this is made
Why it matters
- constraint A simulation of epithelial or biofilm flow built on apolar active nematic assumptions cannot produce co-rotating defect spirals at all, so any prediction that depends on handedness or on dissipation near defects comes out wrong by construction.
- capability Tying entropy production to specific defect events gives modellers a way to put a number on the energy a living layer spends reorganising itself, which apolar theory had no reason to track.
- decision Anyone modelling collective cell flow now has a model with one extra parameter, the strength of polar self-propulsion, and has to justify leaving it at zero for their particular tissue or colony.
A nematic tracks alignment and little else: rod-shaped objects line up and flow together, and self-moving bacteria or cells in that state are called an active nematic [15]. Because a nematic does not care which end points forward, the textbook prediction comes out mirror-symmetric, with a defect pair approaching and separating along straight, perfectly mirrored lines [5]. Living cells do register direction. They burn chemical fuel and move the way they point, and when the group wrote that polar propulsion into a nematically ordered model, a twisting torque appeared at the core of the defect [9][10]. Clockwise or counterclockwise, it holds each defect on a spiral from the moment it forms until it collides with its partner and disappears [10].
The measurement spans two systems picked to be far apart: fast-swarming Bacillus subtilis and slow-crawling human bronchial epithelial cells [3]. That pairing makes the result hard to explain away. A swarming rod-shaped bacterium and a crawling epithelial cell share little mechanically, so an account built on one organism's propulsion hardware or one cell type's adhesions will not cover both [3]. They do share self-propulsion, the term the model adds [9].
The authors also measured irreversibility. Run the film of an annihilation backwards and you do not get a creation; entropy production quantifies that gap, and the researchers report defect creation and destruction as major irreversible drivers of energy dissipation in living systems [8].
The base for all of this is two biological systems, one bacterial species and one human cell type [16]. The phys.org account does not say how many defect pairs were tracked or how large any handedness bias was, and it describes no preparation that has nematic alignment without propulsion, and no observation inside an intact airway [17]. The model asks for that third experiment: switch off self-propulsion, keep the alignment, and the spirals should flatten back into the mirrored paths standard theory predicts [10][5]. The source describes distinct clockwise or counterclockwise trajectories, wording consistent with each pair choosing its own handedness [6].
The write-up goes further, to bacterial colonies coordinating into drug-resistant biofilms and epithelial layers directing cellular traffic to close wounds [11]. Those are the processes this physics is meant to inform. The team measured defect trajectories and entropy production in cell layers [7][8]. "Our findings demonstrate that the self-propelling nature of individual cells fundamentally reshapes collective behavior at larger scales," the researchers wrote [12]. The paper is "Irreversibility and symmetry breaking in the creation and annihilation of defects in active living matter," in Nature Physics [14].
What to watch
- A non-motile or passive control in the same geometry, which would test whether the spiral vanishes when self-propulsion does.
- Replication of the co-rotation in other crawling cell types and other swarming species, by groups outside this collaboration.
- Whether the published paper's supplementary data reports handedness statistics and defect-pair counts the press summary omits.