Invest1 publisher3 min readPublished
Better.com's founder and the investor who replaced him take their texts to an Oct. 20 vote
Vishal Garg and Daniel Lewis are arguing through SEC filings, X threads and a 13-month text log ahead of a shareholder vote that decides who runs a mortgage lender the market values at $230 million.
The Investor · Invest desk
What happened
- Better.com ousted founder Vishal Garg as CEO this summer and installed board member Daniel Lewis as interim chief executive.
- Control of the publicly traded lender now goes to a shareholder vote with an Oct. 20 contest deadline, and the holders deciding it include Activant Capital, Framework Ventures and SoftBank Capital Partners.
- Better's board says the company accumulated more than $2 billion in net losses and lost more than 90% of its value as a public enterprise under Garg's tenure.
- Better disclosed an internal-control weakness in its 2023 and 2024 annual reports after an outside law firm reviewed its culture and faulted the tone set by its CEO.
Compiled by The InvestorSomething wrong?How this is made
Why it matters
- exposure Lewis runs the company from the CEO seat on 2% to 3% of the stock, worth $4.6 million to $6.9 million at the current market value, so his tenure depends on how a handful of outside funds vote rather than on what he owns.
- decision Holders have to price two true records at once: $2.09 billion of losses since 2021, and a 2025 in which the loss finally came in at about 1.01 times revenue.
- precedent A founder who keeps his board seat after losing the CEO job can run a public proxy fight against his own replacement. Future boards will have to settle that term before they promote an investor-director.
Add the five years of net losses in Better's own annual reports and the board's headline figure holds: $301 million in 2021, $877.1 million in 2022, $536.4 million in 2023, $206.3 million in 2024 and $165.9 million in 2025 come to $2.087 billion [14][1]. The market values the company at $230 million [9]. The equity is worth about 11 cents for every dollar of loss booked since 2021 [2].
The same filings carry the other side of the case. Better has sold mortgages online since 2014 and runs an AI product called Tinman for approving and closing loans [4]; revenue went from $72.3 million in 2023 to $108.5 million in 2024 to $164.9 million in 2025 [15]. Over the same stretch the net loss fell from 7.4 times revenue to 1.01 times [3][4]. Add revenue and net loss together as a crude proxy for what the business spends and the number drops from roughly $609 million to roughly $331 million, down 46% [5]. The annual reports do not attribute the improvement, so a vote cast on that trend is a bet it continues.
Lewis founded Orange Capital 20 years ago, invested in Better in 2025, and holds between 2% and 3% of the stock [19]. At $230 million that stake is worth $4.6 million to $6.9 million [6]. His position as interim CEO therefore runs through other people's shares: Activant Capital, Framework Ventures and SoftBank Capital Partners are among the holders who will settle the contest by its Oct. 20 deadline [10]. Fortune puts Lewis's stake at 2% to 3% and leaves Garg's holding unquantified [21].
The text log is the unusual part of this record. Garg gave Fortune a log showing at least 2,000 messages between the two men from July 2025 to August 2026 [20], about five a day [8]. Hours after the ouster, past midnight, Lewis wrote: "You are in my heart, whether you believe it or not." [2] In April, Garg had texted Lewis about becoming "BFFs" [3]. By the end of a seven-part thread on X, Lewis had called his predecessor a "bully" [6] and written, "The love died when the diligence began." [8]
Garg's defence of the December 2021 Zoom call on which he laid off 900 employees [12] is a cash argument. "But it also saved the company because the company was burning $100 million a month, right? We had too many people," he said [13]. Held for a year, that rate is $1.2 billion, four times the $301 million net loss Better reported for 2021 [7]. Garg did not say how long the burn ran, and cash burn and net loss are not the same measure.
In my view the 2025 figures are the more persuasive document, because the cumulative ledger the board cites leans on 2022, a year already closed when Lewis bought in [19]. Share counts decide proxy contests, not ratios, and if Garg's own bloc is short of a majority the trend argument does not decide the vote. The governance record cuts the other way: Better disclosed the tone-at-the-top control weakness in its 2023 and 2024 annual reports [16], reported it remediated as of Dec. 31, 2025 [18], and removed Garg the following summer [1].
What to watch
- Any SEC filing that puts a number on Garg's own holding. That number is what actually decides the Oct. 20 count.
- Whether Activant Capital, Framework Ventures or SoftBank Capital Partners says publicly how it intends to vote.
- Better's next reported quarter, and whether the 1.01 times loss-to-revenue ratio of 2025 holds.