Invest1 publisher3 min readPublished
Korea weighs quadrupling the freight subsidy on non-Middle East crude
The trade ministry summoned SK Energy, GS Caltex, S-Oil and HD Hyundai Oilbank on the 14th, with spot Dubai crude up 53% in five weeks and the freight differential rate, once 100% and now 25%, back under review.
The Investor · Invest desk
What happened
- South Korea's Ministry of Trade and Industry held an emergency crude supply meeting on the 14th at the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry in central Seoul, chaired by Vice Minister Moon Shin-hak.
- Saudi Arabia's East-West Pipeline, which had been moving crude to market as an alternative to the Strait of Hormuz, halted after being hit by drones launched from Iraq, and repairs will take considerable time.
- The ninth round of an oil price cap in place since March 13 expires on the 18th, and industry officials expect the government to extend it for another term.
Compiled by The InvestorSomething wrong?How this is made
Why it matters
- constraint A cargo leaving Yanbu that avoids Bab el-Mandeb and goes through Suez needs roughly 30 extra days at sea, so refiners have to bridge the gap from stock or other grades before any freight decision is taken.
- decision With September and October import volumes already secured at more than 90% of year-earlier levels, a higher subsidy would only reach cargoes not yet bought, so its first effect falls on later loadings.
- exposure Saudi Arabia sold Korea $16.046 billion of crude in the first seven months, 31.3% of the bill, which concentrates the import book on the one supplier whose pipeline is out of service.
- cost LNG prices track crude, and because the Middle East supplies little of Korea's LNG the pressure comes through price, reaching households later through electricity and heating bills.
Singapore gasoline at $147.90 on the 11th was 26.8% above a month earlier, which puts the earlier quote at about $116.64 [9][2]. Dubai spot was $80.80 on Aug 7 and $123.70 on the 11th, a rise of 53.1% [8][1]. The two series are not quoted on the same day. On the figures given, the gasoline premium over Dubai went from roughly $35.84 to $24.20, a narrowing of about $11.60 a barrel, or 32% [3][4][5]. Naphtha rose 15.2% over the same month [9].
The freight differential subsidy works on the cost side. The rate had been lifted to 100% before being cut back to 25%, so restoring it would quadruple what a refiner recovers on the freight gap [4][6]. It pays the difference in shipping cost, not the difference in crude price, and the stated purpose is to make barrels from the Americas, Africa and Southeast Asia easier to buy [4]. "We are consulting with related ministries so that refiners can receive larger freight differential payments when they bring in alternative crude," a government official said, in remarks reported by Seoul Economic Daily [5]. The report includes no budget and no per-barrel figure.
The price cap runs the other way. It has been in place since March 13, was introduced on the assumption that it would run about six months, and the ninth round expires on the 18th [14]. If it is extended while Dubai holds near $123.70, the freight payment is the only one of the two measures that lowers a refiner's delivered cost [8][14][4].
The pipeline could come back, and Seoul is watching for it: "We will keep monitoring the restart of Saudi Arabia's pipeline and mobilize every available policy tool, including support for detour routes through the Suez Canal," a government official said [7]. The constraint on Saudi barrels is physical, since the East-West line was hit by drones launched from Iraq and repairs will take considerable time, so a larger freight payment does not create cargoes [11]. And the review may end with the rate at 25%, since what the ministry has done so far is examine whether to raise it [3][4].
I would expect the cap decision to be settled before the freight rate moves, because the cap has a fixed expiry on the 18th while the freight change needs other ministries to agree [14][5]. If Dubai retraces toward $80.80 and the East-West line restarts, the sourcing question closes without the rate changing at all [8][11]. A freight subsidy decision turns on official selling prices and charter rates. The Korea Petroleum Quality & Distribution Authority plans to commission research on the 11th for a supply stability index covering both, quantified by supplier [16].
What to watch
- Whether the trade ministry lifts the freight differential rate above 25%, and by how much, after the interministerial consultation it described.
- Whether the ninth round of the oil price cap, expiring on the 18th, is extended for another term.
- A restart of Saudi Arabia's East-West Pipeline, and whether Dubai spot retraces toward the $80.80 it traded on Aug. 7.