Invest1 publisher3 min readPublished
Housing stocks fell five times as far as financials on a one-tenth-point PPI surprise
August wholesale prices ran 5.4% against a 5.3% forecast and the ten-year yield added 10.7 basis points. Housing and the private-market managers absorbed most of Thursday's selling while the banks barely moved.
The Investor · Invest desk
What happened
- The ten-year US Treasury yield jumped 10.7 basis points to 4.944% during Thursday afternoon trading.
- Financials moved far less, with the NYSE Financial Index down 0.5% and the State Street Financial Select Sector SPDR ETF down 0.4%.
- The European Central Bank raised its three key rates by 25 basis points as the energy shock from the Middle East war pushed euro-area inflation above its 2% medium-term target.
Compiled by The InvestorSomething wrong?How this is made
Why it matters
- contradiction The annual and monthly readings point opposite ways: repeat August's 0.4% for a year and wholesale inflation runs near 4.9%, below the 5.4% that moved the bond market.
- exposure The private-market managers absorbed the real damage, and TPG's fall at roughly ten times the financials ETF says what got repriced was exit valuations and financing cost, not deposit franchises.
- constraint Any bidder for Lyric now discounts at 4.944%, and the roughly $5 billion figure Reuters reported was struck before the yield moved.
- cost Euro-area borrowers pay for the Middle East energy shock twice, once in energy prices and again in the ECB's tightening.
A tenth of a percentage point is the entire inflation surprise. Wholesale prices rose 5.4% from a year earlier in August against the 5.3% forecast in a Bloomberg-compiled survey [1], so ten basis points of upside met a ten-year Treasury that added 10.7 basis points to 4.944% [4][1]. The monthly figure landed where the survey put it, 0.4% after July's 0.1% [2].
Compound that 0.4% twelve times and the annualized pace is about 4.9% [2], under the 5.4% twelve-month reading [1]. August was still the fastest year-over-year print since May [3].
The selling sorted by rate sensitivity. The Philadelphia Housing Index fell 2.1% and the State Street real estate SPDR 0.9%, against 0.4% for the financials SPDR and 0.5% for the NYSE Financial Index [5][6]. Housing took about five and a quarter times the loss of the broad financials ETF [3].
Inside financials, the worst marks went to the managers whose books are valued off exit prices. TPG fell 4.1% after Reuters reported it is exploring a sale of the healthcare software company Lyric at about $5 billion [14][15], roughly ten times the financials SPDR's decline [4]. Blackstone fell 2.7% on the day it said private equity funds affiliated with Blackstone Capital Partners and Blackstone Energy Transition Partners had signed a deal to buy Flow Control from Audax Private Equity [12][13]. Apollo fell 1.9% while Bloomberg reported that Apollo Sports Capital is interested in investing in an NFL team, according to chief executive Al Tylis at Bloomberg's Power Players New York event [10][11].
The other rate news came from Frankfurt, where the European Central Bank lifted its three key rates by 25 basis points as the energy shock from the Middle East war pushes euro-area inflation above the 2% medium-term target [9]. Bitcoin fell 1.5% to $77,084 and Coinbase 1% [7][17], on a day when Bloomberg reported that Brian Armstrong expects the $300 billion stablecoin market to grow tenfold by 2030, or $3 trillion [16][5].
In my view Thursday was a discount-rate day and not a credit day, and the ordering of the losses is the evidence: the fee-and-carry businesses fell multiples of the deposit-heavy index, while initial jobless claims at 206,000 in the week ended Sept. 5 stayed within a thousand of both the prior week's upwardly revised 207,000 and the 205,000 forecast [8][6]. The counter-case is the in-line monthly print [2]: on that reading the bond market moved 10.7 basis points on a tenth of a point and a foreign central bank.
September's monthly PPI decides between them. At 0.5% the annualized pace is about 6.2% [7] and the twelve-month figure has room to rise; at another 0.4% the twelve-month rate drifts toward 4.9% [2] and Thursday's 10.7 basis points [4] were expensive.
What to watch
- September's monthly PPI: 0.5% annualizes near 6.2%, another 0.4% pulls the twelve-month rate down toward 4.9%.
- Whether TPG's Lyric process prints near the roughly $5 billion Reuters reported with the ten-year at 4.944%.
- Initial claims breaking out of the 205,000 to 207,000 band that has held forecast and print together.