Invest1 publisher3 min readPublished Updated
Musinsa's preferred holders traded a repayment claim for 19% of the equity
Musinsa's preferred investors gave up the right to demand their money back and took common stock instead. The swap lifts 849.9 billion won of liabilities off a balance sheet heading into next year's IPO review.
The Investor · Invest desk
What happened
- Musinsa began converting its redeemable convertible preferred shares in March and finished converting all of them into common stock early this month, after discussions with its investors.
- The company had issued three classes of RCPS across six rounds between 2019 and 2023, raising more than 560 billion won from investors.
- The conversion turned 39,309,500 preferred shares outstanding at the end of last year into 39,337,186 common shares, and all 204,629,016 shares outstanding are now common stock.
- The debt-to-equity ratio, which the preferred-share liabilities had pushed as high as 812%, is put at between 130% and 140% on industry estimates.
Compiled by The InvestorSomething wrong?How this is made
Why it matters
- constraint No holder can now demand repayment of the more than 560 billion won, so Musinsa's cash is beyond reach of a redemption call during the listing process.
- decision Holders of 19.2% of the shares now get paid by selling stock, so the listing price sets their return.
- capability A ratio near 130% lets Musinsa enter IPO review without having to explain an 812% figure that came from an accounting classification.
- contradiction The conversion reads as pre-listing housekeeping to industry sources, while the company says nothing is finalized on procedures or timing. That reading rests on the unnamed sources.
The 849.9 billion won of preferred-share and conversion-right liabilities on Musinsa's books at the end of June was about 1.5 times the more than 560 billion won those six funding rounds actually raised [2]. The gap is accounting. Musinsa classified the preferreds as financial liabilities when it adopted K-IFRS last year, because the investors' redemption rights were judged to leave the company obligated to repay the investment. The value of the conversion right was booked separately as a derivative liability [8]. Interest accrued on the amount owed, and the derivative was revalued each period [10].
The ratio can be run backwards. Assume moving that 849.9 billion won into equity is the only change [9]. A ratio of 812% [7] landing between 130% and 140% [11] then implies equity of roughly 290 to 300 billion won before the conversion, and total liabilities near 2.4 trillion won [3][4]. On those numbers the preferred stack was about 35% of everything Musinsa owed [5]. The 130 to 140% range is an industry estimate [11].
The share count barely moved: 39,309,500 preferred shares became 39,337,186 common, 27,686 more, a ratio of about 1.0007 to one [4][6]. Because every preferred converted, Musinsa paid out nothing to redeem any of them [2].
"For a company heading for a listing, converting RCPS into common stock is an essential and natural step toward improving its financial structure," an industry official told en.sedaily.com [12]. The same official said: "By wrapping up the conversion successfully, Musinsa has pre-emptively resolved the distortion in its debt ratio that could have been a stumbling block during the IPO review" [13].
An RCPS holder can demand repayment of the investment or convert into common stock under certain conditions [17], and the holders of what is now 19.2% of the share count took the stock [1]. "Through smooth discussions with our investors, we converted all of the RCPS into common stock," a Musinsa official said [15]. On timing, the same official said: "Nothing has been specifically finalized regarding further IPO procedures or the timetable" [16].
Two readings fit the record. Either the holders expect a listing price above their entry cost and wanted the upside, or they judged a repayment claim on this company to be worth less than common stock in it. The report does not include the prices at which the six rounds between 2019 and 2023 were struck [3]. Musinsa is aiming at the first half of next year and says the timetable is unset [1][16]. I'd take the conversion as a necessary condition for an IPO review. The test arrives with the second-half numbers. Musinsa's 15.6 billion won consolidated net loss in the first half is attributed in substantial part to RCPS accounting [14]. With the instruments gone, the interest expense and the derivative revaluation stop [10]. A second-half loss of similar size would mean the accounting was not the main cause.
What to watch
- Third-quarter consolidated statements showing whether the debt-to-equity ratio actually lands between 130% and 140%.
- Any listing application or named underwriters, which would put a date on the timetable Musinsa says is not finalized.
- Disclosure of the conversion prices for the three RCPS classes, which would show what the 2019 to 2023 investors paid in.