Skip to content

Invest1 publisher3 min readPublished

Carney asks money managers holding $70 trillion for about 1% of it over five years

The first Canada Investment Summit opens in Toronto with a prospectus of more than 160 projects, while new 50% US tariffs on $20 billion of Canadian goods carry a duty bill of $10 billion a year at unchanged volumes.

The Investor · Invest desk

Photograph accompanying Carney asks money managers holding $70 trillion for about 1% of it over five years
Photo: bnnbloomberg.ca

What happened

  • New 50% US tariffs cover $20 billion of Canadian goods and land on small and medium-sized firms, including family businesses, that had been largely sheltered from the trade war until now.
  • Carney's first Canada Investment Summit runs Monday and Tuesday in Toronto, drawing money managers who collectively oversee more than $70 trillion in assets.
  • Carney wants C$1 trillion of government and private investment over five years, funded partly by privatizing public assets such as airports and by pro-business tax and regulatory reform.

Compiled by The InvestorSomething wrong?How this is made

Why it matters

  • constraint A duty equal to half the invoice leaves the exposed exporters absorbing $10 billion a year between them or stopping shipments, and neither choice is repaired by a five-year capital programme.
  • decision Selling airports and other public assets to fund the transition is a decision Ottawa has to make before any investor in Toronto has put a number on paper.
  • exposure Foreign funds that write cheques take on the Canadian permitting risk that New York investors once mocked by renaming a federal statute.
  • contradiction TD's chief executive calls this a super-cycle while the same account describes lagging per capita GDP and weak business investment, so investors are being asked to price a recovery the growth data does not yet show.

Carney's C$1 trillion goal converts to $720 billion, and the asset managers arriving in Toronto oversee more than $70 trillion between them, so the five-year target is 1.03% of the money in the room [12][6][1]. Annually that is about a fifth of a percent [6], or C$200 billion a year of new investment, roughly $144 billion [2]. The target counts government money alongside private dollars, and Bloomberg's account does not break the split [12]. "There are very few people who get up in the morning and think about Canada," Carney has said [13].

The cost side is smaller and easier to size. A 50% duty on $20 billion of goods is $10 billion a year if volumes hold, and at that rate a good deal of it stops moving instead [3]. Jobs data already point to strain in auto parts and forestry, in what the account calls the world's 10th-biggest economy [2][3]. The annual investment target is about 14 times the gross duty bill [4].

Investors get a prospectus of more than 160 projects needing hundreds of billions of dollars, spanning data centres, advanced manufacturing, LNG terminals, ports and dozens of mines [9]. Take the lowest reading of that phrase, $200 billion, and the projects average $1.25 billion each [5]. "Canada is one of the most connected economies in the world. We have trade deals covering 1.5 billion consumers," Carney said in an interview with Bloomberg News [8]. "We have a super-cycle of investment opportunity that I just have not seen in my career," Toronto-Dominion Bank chief executive Raymond Chun said [10].

Growth in per capita GDP has lagged other major economies on weak business investment and stubbornly low productivity gains [16]. Some investors had come to see Canada as an unpredictable place to put money after high-profile resource projects were delayed, rejected or abandoned [17]. Heather Exner-Pirot of the Macdonald-Laurier Institute said the country's "investability reputation was severely harmed" during Justin Trudeau's decade in office [18]. She recalled New York investors derisively calling the 2019 Impact Assessment Act the "Don't Invest in Canada Act" [19]. Carney does not dispute the diagnosis. "We've been slow on moving on a series of areas with respect to regulatory approvals and other factors," he said [20].

Carney entered politics last year and rode anti-Trump sentiment to a surprise fourth straight Liberal win [15]. That goodwill is finite, and he is spending it on privatizing airports and rewriting tax and regulatory rules [4], not on a negotiated tariff settlement; he walked away from the talks with Trump [5]. Measures to speed approvals went in last year, and more are promised: "We're going to double down on that strategy, you'll see in the coming weeks, with additional measures that spread that across the economy," Carney said [21].

I would price this as a list of intentions until a number is signed, since none of Blackstone, Temasek or Apollo Global Management has committed an amount, according to Bloomberg [7][22]. Chun said he could not recall another time a similar group of the world's leading asset managers met to discuss investing in Canada [11]. Statutory change to the 2019 review law among the measures Carney promised for the coming weeks would settle it. So would a named fund putting a dollar figure against one of the 160 projects.

What to watch

  • Whether the additional measures Carney promised for the coming weeks amend the 2019 Impact Assessment Act or only add administrative speed.
  • Any named commitment with a dollar figure from Blackstone, Temasek or Apollo after the Toronto summit closes.
  • Whether the airport privatizations get published valuations, and what the next jobs data show for auto parts and forestry.
Loading claim ledger
Loading source directory links
Loading share composer
Loading topic controls
Loading related stories