Skip to content

Science1 publisher2 min readPublished

Escape neurons in glassfish fire when a virtual neighbour vanishes from the screen

A UC San Diego team imaged thousands of neurons in transparent 12-millimetre fish watching computer-generated schools, and found midbrain cells that treat a partner's sudden absence much as they treat a partner's flight.

The Scientist · Science desk

Photograph accompanying Escape neurons in glassfish fire when a virtual neighbour vanishes from the screen
Photo: ucsd.edu

What happened

  • UC San Diego neurobiologists report in Nature a neural signature of social action detection in an ancient visual midbrain circuit that exists across fish, birds and primates.
  • The animal is the glassfish Danionella cerebrum, about 12 millimetres long and transparent enough that brain activity can be measured noninvasively under an optical microscope.
  • Faced with a rapidly approaching object standing in for a predator, groups of glassfish escaped more effectively than individual fish and used vision to scatter away from each other.
  • Midbrain neurons driven by a partner's escape also responded when a partner suddenly vanished from view, and the fish retreated from on-screen schools that escaped or disappeared.
  • The retreat appeared only when the on-screen partners swam in the species' burst-and-glide rhythm, and the fish ignored schools moving with smooth, nonbiological motion.

Compiled by The ScientistSomething wrong?How this is made

Why it matters

  • capability A virtual conspecific separates the social cue from the threat itself, so an experimenter can now present an alarm with nothing alarming in the tank and ask what the brain does with it.
  • constraint The conserved-circuit framing is about anatomy shared between taxa, and confirming that a flock of starlings or a primate uses it for the same job requires recordings in those animals.
  • decision Anyone modelling collective escape has a concrete substitute for a generic information-sharing term: species-typical motion, plus a partner's absence from an expected position, both of which can be scored from video.

Geoff Meyerhof, a postdoctoral fellow in the lab, made the social cue available without a predator. He designed schools of virtual Danionella in video game software, realistic enough in appearance, posture and movement that real fish came and swam alongside them at the screen [5]. When the on-screen school suddenly fled, the real fish scattered as though a threat were present, with nothing approaching the tank [6]. Seeing a partner escape is sufficient on its own [16].

That design has an obvious failure mode. A fish might be startled by any object that shoots off or drops out of view, social or not. The smooth-motion condition addresses it: the same virtual school, gliding along with non-biological smooth motion, neither recruited real fish nor alarmed them [8]. The authors concluded that the glassfish brain identifies social partners by the natural movement pattern of its own species, and is highly sensitive to their sudden disappearance from an expected position [9].

The recordings covered thousands of neurons across the brain, read through a transparent body about 12 millimetres long with an optical microscope [3][4]. What they give is a correlation. Neurons that respond when a partner flees have not been shown to cause the flight, and the account describes recordings without perturbations [18]. The release does not include group sizes or escape rates [17].

The same lab had already shown that glassfish school by watching and copying their neighbours' actions [15]. "Each fish in the group sees their neighbors move, and moves in response," said Matthew Lovett-Barron, the assistant professor of neurobiology whose lab ran the work, describing the interaction that produces schooling [13]. "The ability to pay attention to each other helps these fish detect danger as well," he added [14]. In the real schools, fish on the far side from the looming object escaped when they could see nearer neighbours fleeing it [12].

The sensitivity to a partner's absence fits where this animal lives. Danionella cerebrum is found in murky water and may not be able to see very far there, which the authors compare to human vision in dense fog, where fast-moving items can seem to vanish from view [10]. Jo-Hsien Yu, who led the study as a doctoral student in the lab, reported the result in Nature [2][1].

What to watch

  • Whether the escape-responsive population separates into cells tuned to a partner's flight and cells tuned to a partner's absence.
  • A version of the experiment run at different water clarities, which would show whether the disappearance response tracks how far a fish can see.
  • Recordings from the homologous midbrain region in a bird or a mammal watching a conspecific flee.
Loading claim ledger
Loading source directory links
Loading share composer
Loading topic controls
Loading related stories