Skip to content

Invest1 publisher3 min readPublished

319 investors file a 32 billion won bond complaint with an office that shuts next month

South Korea's Prosecution Service is dissolved in under a month, and the agency taking over serious financial crime is at least three weeks from opening, so a complaint filed on the 8th has nobody able to trace accounts.

The Investor · Invest desk

Illustration accompanying 319 investors file a 32 billion won bond complaint with an office that shuts next month

What happened

  • South Korea abolishes its Prosecution Service in under a month, replacing it with a new Public Prosecution Office and a Serious Crimes Investigation Agency.
  • The Serious Crimes Investigation Agency takes over jurisdiction for serious financial crimes starting next month, and could be at least three weeks from opening its doors.
  • On the 8th, 319 investors filed a complaint with the Seoul Southern District Prosecutors' Office against 20 people over a 32 billion won Joongang Group bond case, citing the Capital Markets Act.

Compiled by The InvestorSomething wrong?How this is made

Why it matters

  • constraint Both routes the complainants named are impaired at the same time: prosecutors cannot practically open the case, and the FSS unit prosecutors used to direct is losing that direction as prosecutorial investigative powers end.
  • cost Spread evenly, each of the 319 complainants carries about 100 million won whose recovery depends on account and electronic records surviving the transition intact.
  • capability The body inheriting authority over serious financial crime may not be the body holding the experience, because ex-prosecution financial investigators are being taken on by the FSS.
  • precedent Complaints filed in the next month test whether a filing alone still triggers compulsory measures, or whether victims must hire counsel to press two agencies for a raid.

Five days after those investors filed, legal sources told Seoul Economic Daily that prosecutors cannot practically open new direct investigations with less than a month left before their own service is dissolved [5]. Referral to the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency means a wait of at least three weeks until that agency opens [6]. Add the five days already gone and at least 26 days pass between the complaint and the first day a body with jurisdiction exists [17]. Whether it can then order large-scale raids and account tracing depends on its offices, computer networks and case management systems being sufficiently in place [7].

The complainants asked for one of two things: a direct prosecution investigation, or a swift referral to the Financial Supervisory Service's special judicial police so raids could proceed [10]. The second route is in transition too, because the system under which prosecutors direct that unit is ending along with prosecutorial investigative powers [8]. In market manipulation, unfair trading and large-scale financial fraud, the work is tracing fund flows quickly and securing account and electronic records early, and when cases drift funds get moved and records disappear [9].

Split the case across the complainants and it is about 100 million won each, if the 32 billion won is spread evenly [16]. Lee Bok-hyun, the former FSS governor who leads the investors' legal team, said financial crime cases involving large numbers of victims have typically been taken up by prosecutors or the FSS on their own initiative. That did not happen this time [11]. "As the judicial system undergoes major change and investigative authority is scattered across multiple agencies, the range of matters victims must handle themselves has widened," Lee said [12].

Staffing is the second problem. The new agency will not find it easy to inherit the Prosecution Service's financial crime investigation capacity in a short period, and the shortage of specialists is the biggest obstacle [18]. A lawyer who formerly worked at the joint investigation unit for financial and securities crimes cited assessments of the prosecution personnel who applied to move to the new agency. Few of them have extensive experience investigating financial cases, the lawyer said [13]. The report does not say how many applied [19].

Six people from the prosecution were selected in the FSS's recruitment of specialist and experienced hires at grades 4 and 5 last month [14]. Some financial investigation personnel are going to the FSS instead of the new agency. The expectation is that the centre of gravity in financial investigations moves to its special judicial police [15].

If the agency opens with working systems and traces September complaints in its first weeks, the gap was a scheduling matter. If the FSS special judicial police ends up with the cases and the people, the new agency holds the jurisdiction and the FSS holds the experienced investigators [15]. I would expect the second, and those six hires at grades 4 and 5 are the reason [14]. A raid ordered by the new agency, in a financial case, in its first month of operation, would prove me wrong.

What to watch

  • Whether the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency orders account tracing or a raid in a financial case during its first weeks, and whether its case management system is live when it does.
  • Whether the Seoul Southern District Prosecutors' Office refers the 319-investor complaint to the FSS special judicial police before the Prosecution Service is dissolved.
  • Further FSS hiring rounds pulling ex-prosecution financial investigators, after the six selected at grades 4 and 5 last month.
Loading claim ledger
Loading source directory links
Loading share composer
Loading topic controls
Loading related stories