Security2 publishers3 min readPublished
South Africa extradites five alleged Black Axe leaders to face wire fraud counts in New Jersey
The Cape Town Zone of Black Axe ran romance and advance fee scams from 2011 until South African police made arrests in 2021, and the accounts prosecutors traced also carried business email compromise proceeds.
The Watch · Security desk
What happened
- Five alleged leaders of Black Axe's Cape Town Zone were extradited from South Africa and were due before U.S. District Judge Michael Shipp in Trenton, New Jersey, on Monday.
- The Justice Department says the five, all originally from Nigeria, ran romance scams and advance fee scams from at least 2011 until South African police arrested them in 2021.
- All five face conspiracy to commit wire fraud and money laundering, with wire fraud or aggravated identity theft counts added for four of them, and combined exposure of up to 62 years.
- Perry Osagiede helped run several South African companies used to launder the proceeds, and some victims opened separate bank accounts that the scammers then loaded with funds, prosecutors say.
- The Justice Department describes Black Axe as a hierarchical group taking in billions of dollars a year from many small operations across dozens of countries.
Compiled by The WatchSomething wrong?How this is made
Why it matters
- precedent Suspects arrested in South Africa on U.S. fraud charges can now expect to be handed over and arraigned in a U.S. district court.
- exposure A bank chasing romance-scam typologies and a bank chasing business email compromise proceeds can be looking at the same corporate accounts, so the two alert queues describe one laundering network.
- constraint Prosecutors have to prove each man's own wire fraud and laundering conduct, so the zone hierarchy in the indictment is context for a jury.
Some of the laundered money traced back to business email compromise, not only romance fraud, according to prosecutors [11]. The 2021 indictment also describes co-conspirators using business entities and getting into some victims' own financial accounts to hide funds taken from other victims [12]. When victims hesitated to send money, the Justice Department said, members of the group threatened to distribute sensitive photographs of them [13]. Victims were found on social media and dating sites, contacted through apps under aliases [26].
The two accounts of the handover differ on the date. CyberScoop reported the extradition happened Friday [1]. The Record put it on September 11 [2].
Each wire fraud and money laundering count carries a maximum of 20 years, The Record reported [8]. Three of those terms plus two years is the 62-year combined exposure the Justice Department describes [7][9]. Neither outlet reported a racketeering charge [28].
The organizational detail is in how the Justice Department describes the men. It identifies Perry Osagiede as founder and leader of the Cape Town Zone, Franklyn Edosa Osagiede as the zone's "chief ihaza," Osariemen Eric Clement as "assistant eye of the zone," Collins Owhofasa Otughwor as "chief eye," and Musa Mudashiru as one of the group's "assistant butchers" [3]. The branch answered to a headquarters in Benin City, Nigeria, and Perry Osagiede ran its efforts against U.S. residents, prosecutors said [17]. Stefanie Roddy, special agent in charge of the FBI's Newark field office, said in a statement: "Black Axe is a notoriously violent transnational criminal organization that also happens to dabble in romance scams to make money" [14]. Roddy also said the ability to "reach into South Africa illustrates our resolve to hold accountable any and every type of fraudster who preys on innocent victims here in the United States" [15].
This is the fourth publicly reported action against the group this year. Spanish authorities arrested 34 people in January, including some Black Axe leaders, for adversary-in-the-middle fraud such as business email compromise, money laundering and vehicle trafficking [18]. Swiss and German police arrested 10 suspected members in April [21]. CyberScoop describes an August multi-country operation that seized millions in assets, arrested 58 people and identified 263 suspects [19]; The Record describes an Interpol operation two weeks before publication that arrested 58 people across 22 countries, some of whom supplied money laundering services and website domains to Black Axe [20].
The charged losses are a fraction of the reported total. The indictment covers more than 100 victims who lost thousands of dollars each [6]. Even at $10,000 a victim, that is about $1 million, against the $12.7 billion the Treasury Department says Americans have lost to overseas romance and investment scams since 2023 [22][23]. The Justice Department published the aliases and business entities used by the Cape Town Zone and asked other victims to contact the FBI [29].
What to watch
- Whether prosecutors supersede the 2021 indictment with racketeering counts after arraignment in Trenton.
- Whether the South African companies and aliases the Justice Department published turn up in other BEC or laundering cases.
- Whether South Africa approves further Black Axe extraditions on the same fraud statutes.