Science1 publisher2 min readPublished
Fuzzy dark matter simulated as a 3D wave field fits a lensed quasar's image positions
Physicists at HKU and Beijing Normal University derived lensing predictions straight from a three-dimensional wave simulation. On one well-studied quasar, the image positions came out closer to the data than the models they compared against.
The Scientist · Science desk
What happened
- Astrophysicists at the University of Hong Kong, working with a Beijing Normal University-led team, made gravitational-lensing predictions directly from three-dimensional wave simulations of fuzzy dark matter for the first time.
- Those simulations reproduced the observed image positions of a well-studied lensed quasar more closely than the modelling approaches the study used for comparison.
- The group is now extending the work to other lensing observables, including changes in the brightness of the lensed images.
Compiled by The ScientistSomething wrong?How this is made
Why it matters
- capability Ultralight dark matter models now come with image-position predictions computed for a specific lens, so high-resolution imaging can test them without going through an analytic halo approximation.
- constraint One lens system cannot rank dark matter candidates against each other, and the study published no fit statistic; doing that would need a sample of lenses modelled the same way for each candidate.
- exposure The brightness comparison the group is running next can go against the wave model, and if it does, the agreement on positions stops carrying the case for fuzzy dark matter.
Ultralight particles are light enough to behave collectively like waves, and where those waves overlap they produce interference patterns, similar to those formed when waves meet on a beach [5]. Put that pattern inside a galaxy acting as a gravitational lens and it becomes structure in the mass that bends the light. It is fine enough to leave traces in the multiple images of a more distant source [5]. The new work computes those image positions from a three-dimensional simulation of the wave field, so the small-scale pattern comes out of the simulation itself [2].
Dark matter accounts for about 85% of all matter in the universe and has no place in the Standard Model of particle physics [9]. Over the past decade, according to the HKU announcement, growing astronomical evidence has raised the possibility that it consists of ultralight particles [13].
The comparison rests on one lensed quasar [7]. The announcement identifies the alternatives only as "commonly used modeling approaches" and does not give the name of the system, the particle mass assumed, or how much closer the simulated fit was [6]. A wave field with interference structure carries more small-scale freedom than a smooth mass distribution. A closer match to image positions is evidence for the model only when both were fitted with comparable freedom.
The team went in without knowing what the simulations would show. "We were very excited to see what the simulations predicted as we did not know beforehand what observable signatures to expect," the researchers said in the HKU announcement [10].
The paper's lead author is Jiajun Zhou, a doctoral student in professor Zong-Hong Zhu's group at BNU. The collaboration grew out of research visits to Beijing by the HKU physicists Jeremy Lim and Amruth Alfred [11][12]. The paper appears in The Astrophysical Journal Letters under DOI 10.3847/2041-8213/ae9a9e [4].
What to watch
- Results from the brightness comparison the group is running on the same wave simulations.
- A follow-up that publishes per-model fit statistics and parameter counts for the same lens.
- Application of the method to additional lensed quasars, giving a sample rather than one system.